Gee N Jays$
Highest combined evidence in Elgin proper: the city's best Google rating among high-volume spots (4.4 on 201) paired with a strong 4.2 on 90 Yelp reviews, plus a history dating to 1972.
All cities › Illinois › Elgin
Ranked from a comprehensive review of Google and Yelp — rating and review count on both platforms, quality weighed against volume. Elgin population 115,476; figures researched November 2026. How we rank →
Highest combined evidence in Elgin proper: the city's best Google rating among high-volume spots (4.4 on 201) paired with a strong 4.2 on 90 Yelp reviews, plus a history dating to 1972.
Matches Gee N Jays' 4.4 Google rating on a comparable 184 reviews and holds 4.0 on 71 Yelp reviews — the strongest combined profile in the Dundee/Carpentersville corridor.
The area's largest Yelp base at 4.0 on 295 reviews, backed by 4.1 on 205 Google reviews — the most-reviewed quality option on the St. Charles edge.
Perfectly balanced dual-platform evidence — 4.0 on ~200 reviews on both Google and Yelp — and Yelp's No. 1 Chinese listing for Elgin; operating since 1997 with a Lao/Thai menu alongside Chinese staples.
Strong Google showing (4.3 on 198) with a solid 3.7 on 161 Yelp reviews; the downtown St. Charles Sichuan name in scope.
Good Google quality (4.3 on 168) and one of Elgin's larger Yelp bases (151 reviews), though Yelp's 3.4 keeps it below the top five.
Consistent mid-4 Google evidence (4.1 on 135) with a respectable 3.6 on 55 Yelp reviews; a long-running south-side takeout staple.
Google raters like it (4.3 on 118, listed on Yelp as Mr Wok & Boba Glass at 3.4 on 41); smaller Yelp volume caps its rank.
Nearly identical Google quality to Mr. Wok (4.3) on fewer reviews (83), with a slightly better Yelp rating (3.5) on a larger Yelp base (96).
West Dundee's best-regarded Chinese takeout: 4.1 on 86 Google reviews and 3.4 on 48 Yelp reviews, with Yelp reviewers calling it the best Chinese in the area.
Decent combined volume (138 Google, 106 Yelp) but middling ratings on both platforms (3.8 / 3.1) place it in the lower half.
The most polarized entry: Elgin's largest Google base (265 reviews at 3.8) against a poor 2.6 on 155 Yelp reviews — volume keeps it ranked, Yelp drags it down.
The area's main Chinese buffet draws 248 Google reviews at 3.7, but a thin, weak Yelp record (2.7 on 36) limits it to the teens.
A 35-year east-side takeout fixture with modest, below-average scores on both platforms (3.7 Google / 3.2 Yelp) and small review bases.
High Google volume (203 reviews) cannot offset low ratings on both platforms (3.6 Google, 3.1 Yelp).
The reverse split of most rivals: Yelp (3.5 on 91) rates it noticeably better than Google (3.2 on 162); combined evidence is still bottom-tier.
Yelp's small sample loves it (4.2 on just 14 reviews, as New Dragon Buffet) but Google's larger base (listed as Dragon Buffet) rates it only 3.3 on 132 — volume wins the tiebreak against it.
Small, below-average evidence on both platforms (3.5 on 44 Google; 3.2 on 55 Yelp) from the far-west St. Charles edge.
Old-school chop suey house with a weak Google record (3.3 on 99); no Yelp rating/count could be obtained, so it ranks on Google evidence alone.
The chain's South Elgin flagship location (ranked as one location, never summed) closes the list on volume alone — 184 Google reviews — despite 3.2 / 2.8 ratings.
Google figures are as displayed by Restaurantji, which aggregates Google reviews (its list and individual pages show the Google rating and count, e.g. Gee N Jays 4.4/201, Silver Lake 3.8/265); Yelp figures are from Yelp search/listing pages for Elgin, South Elgin, Carpentersville, West Dundee and St. Charles opened directly on 2026-11-16. No rounded counts were used; all counts are exact as displayed. 19 of 20 entries have BOTH platforms complete; Wing Ho Chop Suey has no obtainable Yelp rating/count (null). Judgment calls: (1) White Pearl is ranked as Chinese because Places lists its primary category as Chinese Restaurant and Yelp ranks it No.1 among Elgin Chinese restaurants, but its menu is substantially Lao/Thai/Vietnamese (pho, papaya salad, Laos sausage) — noted in its styles. (2) Excluded as not primarily Chinese despite strong numbers: Fry n' Wings, St. Charles (Google 4.6/265 via Restaurantji, Yelp 4.4/77) — a chicken-wing/Korean-American Asian-fusion spot, not a Chinese restaurant; and Lao & Thai Spicy Noodle, South Elgin (Yelp 4.4/219) — Thai/Lao primary. (3) Scope: Elgin, South Elgin, Carpentersville, West Dundee and the St. Charles edge only, per brief. Well-reviewed Algonquin/Geneva spots that appear in Elgin Yelp searches (Gourmet House 3.9/282 Yelp, China Bistro, Chamber-adjacent Gen Hoe and Cravings in Geneva) are outside the stated immediate surroundings and were not ranked. (4) New Dragon Buffet's Google listing appears under its former/short name 'Dragon Buffet' at the same 551 S 8th St address; figures were matched by address, not summed with anything. (5) Mr. Wok's Yelp listing appears as 'Mr Wok & Boba Glass' (3.4/41). (6) Below the cut: No 1 China / No. 1 China Buffet, South Elgin (Google 3.0/74 via Restaurantji; Yelp listings split between 2.6/76 and 2.4/69, which also made platform matching ambiguous) and Panda Express locations in Elgin/Carpentersville/St. Charles other than the ranked South Elgin flagship. (7) No recently-closed Chinese restaurant with strong evidence was confirmed, so closed_notables is empty. Style diversity is limited in this market — it is dominated by Chinese-American takeout, with one Sichuan-leaning bistro (Chamber Red), one Sichuan namesake (Szechwan), Cantonese carryout (Hong Kong Chef), two buffets, and White Pearl's Lao/Thai-Chinese mix; no dedicated dim sum, hot pot, dumpling, Taiwanese or Shanghainese specialist with verifiable listings exists in the area.