Chengdu$$
The strongest two-platform profile serving Broken Arrow: 4.4 on ~492 Google reviews paired with 4.5 on 137 Yelp reviews for authentic Sichuan cooking in south Tulsa, minutes from Broken Arrow.
All cities › Oklahoma › Broken Arrow
Ranked from a comprehensive review of Google and Yelp — rating and review count on both platforms, quality weighed against volume. Broken Arrow population 124,991; figures researched November 2026. How we rank →
The strongest two-platform profile serving Broken Arrow: 4.4 on ~492 Google reviews paired with 4.5 on 137 Yelp reviews for authentic Sichuan cooking in south Tulsa, minutes from Broken Arrow.
Tulsa's first authentic hot pot restaurant matches 4.5 on Google (438 reviews) with 4.5 on Yelp (116) — the most consistent high scores at real volume in the metro Broken Arrow diners use.
A decades-old family takeout counter with excellent rating quality on both platforms — 4.6 on Google (305 reviews) and 4.5 on Yelp (60) — and a loyal south Tulsa / Broken Arrow following.
Broken Arrow's own flagship and the highest Google rating in this list — 4.7 on 111 reviews via Restaurantji's Google-sourced list (a sibling Tulsa crawl recorded 4.7 on a larger count) — backed by 4.3 on 38 Yelp reviews for authentic Sichuan dishes.
Serving Tulsa since 1983, Golden Gate pairs a large Google base (4.4 on ~817 reviews) with a solid 4.0 on 152 Yelp reviews — proven volume no Broken Arrow-local spot matches.
A long-running Chinese-Malaysian spot on 71st St, the corridor Broken Arrow diners use most: 4.6 on 205 reviews via Restaurantji's Bixby-area list paired with 4.2 on 128 Yelp reviews.
By far the most-reviewed Chinese restaurant in the metro on Google (4.4 on ~2.2K reviews as displayed rounded); a weaker 3.7 Yelp score keeps the chain flagship out of the top tier.
The metro's most-reviewed independent Chinese restaurant on both platforms (Google 4.2 on ~1.2K; Yelp 3.8 on 368, the largest Yelp base in the area) and its best-known Sichuan kitchen, though ratings trail the leaders.
A dual Cantonese/Sichuan kitchen with a strong Google record (4.5 on 408 reviews in the Tulsa research; Restaurantji's newer list shows 4.4 on 242) and a devoted following for its authentic menu; no verifiable Yelp figure was obtained, capping its rank.
Consistently above 4.2 on both platforms (Google 4.4/377, Yelp 4.2/83) — one of the most balanced mid-volume profiles in the metro.
A Tulsa institution since the 1980s with a large Google base (4.4 on ~798 reviews) on Broken Arrow's northwest doorstep; a middling 3.8 Yelp score holds it at #11.
The strongest Yelp record among the metro's authentic kitchens (4.3 on 202 reviews) with a matching 4.3 Google rating; its Google review count could not be verified, so it sits outside the top 10.
Nearly 40 years in far south Tulsa, close to Broken Arrow's southern neighborhoods, with steady scores on both platforms (Google 4.3/320, Yelp 4.0/84).
The highest Google rating at 200+ reviews in the south metro (4.6 on 210 via Restaurantji), serving the Broken Arrow/Bixby Memorial corridor; no verifiable Yelp figure was obtained.
The Memorial Drive dumpling specialist earns 4.6 on Yelp (61 reviews) for handmade soup dumplings; Google figures could not be verified (Restaurantji lists the same address as BaoBao Dumpling and Ramen at 4.4/146 without platform attribution in the list view).
Broken Arrow's best-evidenced local takeout after Szechuan House: 4.2 on 174 reviews via Restaurantji's Broken Arrow list, with reviewers calling its egg rolls the best around; no Yelp figure for the Broken Arrow store could be verified (the Tulsa 71st St store is separate and was not summed).
The south metro's main Chinese buffet, serving Broken Arrow's southern edge: a large Google base (4.2 on 341 via Restaurantji) with a weaker but real Yelp record (3.9 on 59, per Tulsa research notes for East China Restaurant, same address).
A Broken Arrow neighborhood staple with solid Google-sourced evidence (4.2 on 164 via Restaurantji) and effusive delivery reviews; no location-specific Yelp rating/count could be verified.
South Broken Arrow's family-owned takeout favorite: 4.3 on 117 reviews via Restaurantji, praised as the best Chinese takeout in Broken Arrow; no Yelp figure could be verified.
Ranked as the named flagship Broken Arrow location (South Aspen) on Google-sourced evidence alone (4.3 on 169 via Restaurantji); the separate Hillside Dr store (3.3 on 250) was not summed in, and as a fast-food chain it takes the final slot below every independent with stronger evidence.
SCOPE: Broken Arrow proper has only about a dozen Chinese restaurants (Restaurantji lists 11 of 13), so per the project scope the Tulsa metro that serves Broken Arrow is included and each entry's actual municipality is recorded in locality: 5 entries are in Broken Arrow, 1 in Bixby, 14 in Tulsa. GOOGLE FIGURES: For Tulsa entries, Google/Yelp pairs are those verified in the sibling Tulsa research file (tulsa-ok.json, researched 2026-11-16) and re-checked against Restaurantji lists opened 2026-11-16/17, which sometimes show newer/smaller crawls (e.g. Chengdu 4.3/227 and Mandarin Taste 4.1/462 on Restaurantji vs the pairs recorded). For Broken Arrow/Bixby locals and Yummy Asia/Asian Fusion, Google rating/count are Restaurantji list figures, which aggregate Google reviews (its business pages label individual reviews 'on Google'); the pair recorded is the one seen on the Broken Arrow or Bixby list opened during this research. Szechuan House is the exception: Restaurantji shows 4.7/111 while the Tulsa file recorded Google 4.7/231 via PublicLeads - the 111 figure actually seen on the list opened here is recorded. YELP GAPS: Yelp pages for most Broken Arrow-local takeouts (Egg Roll Street, Happy House, Kuai Zi, China One, No 1 Kitchen, Oriental Garden, Pei Wei Broken Arrow, Panda Express Broken Arrow) are not indexed in search and no rating/count could be verified, so Yelp is null for those entries rather than guessed; the same applies to Yummy Asia and Gigi's. That is why only 12 of 20 entries have both platforms' rating+count. ROUNDED COUNTS: P.F. Chang's Google reviews displayed as '2.2K' (recorded 2200) and Mandarin Taste as '1.2K' (recorded 1200) by Top-Rated.online. JUST BELOW THE CUT: Hiya Chili, Tulsa (Yelp 4.6/31, dim sum - thin evidence), Pepper Express, Bixby (4.3/141 via Restaurantji, Google only), Nana's Dim Sum & Dumplings, Tulsa (4.0/79 via Restaurantji, opened Aug 2026), China One, Broken Arrow (3.7/134), No 1 Kitchen, Broken Arrow (3.9/275), Oriental Garden, Broken Arrow (4.0/178), Pei Wei, Broken Arrow (3.7/333), Fortune Chef, Tulsa (Google 4.0/225), Maple Garden, Jenks (Google 4.0/107, Yelp 4.2/50), and Dragon China, Tulsa (4.3/99). EXCLUDED: Toyosu Buffet, Broken Arrow (3.2/348) as primarily a Japanese/sushi buffet, Egg Roll Express, Broken Arrow (2.1/121 via Restaurantji) for failing the evidence/quality bar, and HuHot Mongolian Grill as Mongolian BBQ rather than Chinese. No Michelin coverage exists for the Tulsa area; longevity/press used only as tiebreak color.